Congress needs to fight fire with fire by responding to the symbolic act of burning old glory with symbolic action of its owneach new congress. Cnn student news one story we brought you this week concerned a teacher who, as part of a class exercise, burned the american flag in a civics. Speaker, i rise in support of the rule, although unenthusiastically. Yes it is perfectly legal to burn the american flag. Flag burning is a potent symbolic gesture conveying sharp criticism of the state. The concept of flag desecration continues to provoke a heated debate over. With her on the briefs were john vance and dolena t. A group of protesters set fire to multiple american flags, resulting in a fight with onlookers. Looking through texas vs johnson, we examine the constitutional arguments foragainst flag burning. Nov, 2019 flag burning is a potent symbol of protest in the united states, conveying sharp criticism of the state and stirring a deeply emotional, nearly religious fury in many of its citizens. When i see someone burning a flag i get offended for different reasons. The court noted, however, that speechneutral laws, such as those applicable to public burning generally, might be constitutionally applied against flag burners. Flag burner fights back with federal lawsuit new lenox, il photos depicting an urbana man burning an american flag stirred the wrath of the internet.
In the case of a national flag, such action is often intended to make a political point against a country or its policies. Johnson was tried and convicted under a texas law outlawing flag desecration. Burning the flag is akin to denouncing these values that are symbols of the country. In 1989 a political fire storm erupted after the united states supreme court declared that dissidents had the constitutional right under the first amendment to burn the flag. The court found that johnsons actions fell into the category of expressive conduct and had a distinctively political nature. When the supreme court ruled to allow american flag burning. Flagburner fights back with federal lawsuit new lenox, il photos depicting an urbana man burning an american flag stirred the wrath of the internet. The flag desecration amendment, also known as the flag burning amendment, is a very controversial amendment allowed under the constitution. A history of flagburning and flag desecration laws in the.
Burning a flag is not free speech its a disgrace to our country. Burning or desecrating the flag in any way should be considered an offense to freedom and democracy and should therefore be considered a crime. Right wing extremists took issue and a fight broke out. The flag will be flying proudly long after they have slunk away. This soldiersdiesoprotesterscanburnflags slogan has become a mantra repeated. Black flags the rise of isis from the 1st page this book grips like a superbly written thriller by the likes of tom clancy but its all history and very real in our time, one of the most cinematic books ive read every page is well written and descriptive, a book of the moment and for time to come. The court concluded that the flag burning was speech and again determined that the flag desecration statute was aimed at the communicative impact of johnsons message. Veteran prevents flag burning at independence day trump.
Congress to prohibit by statute and provide punishment for the physical desecration of the flag of the united states. Ap photohasan jamaliprotesters are burning and trampling upon the american flag again. Trump fans in violent clashes with communists after american flag. A group of flagburning antinypd protesters needed new yorks finest to save their skin from a gang of angry bikers who tried to pummel them in a brooklyn park for setting old glory ablaze. How to respond to arguments for banning flag burning. Flag burning is also counterproductive and provocative. Its a grand old flagheres why the right to burn it was affirmed in. Argued march 21, 1989 decided june 21, 1989 certiorari to the court of criminal appeals of texas 398 kathi alyce drew argued the cause for petitioner. Professor robert justin goldstein documented approximately 45 reported incidents of flag burning in the over 200 years between 1777 when the flag was adopted, and 1989, when congress passed, and the supreme court rejected, the flag protection act. The problem, then, with taking the position that the flag should be protected even at the expense of individual liberty is not that flag burning or any other activity deemed to be offensive has some sort of redeeming value, or that symbols such as the flag are unimportant, but that in banning these activities, one is accepting a principle that. But, this flag was the private property of the protrump supporter.
When the supreme court ruled to allow american flag. Flagburning is a potent symbol of protest in the united states, conveying sharp criticism of the state and stirring a deeply emotional, nearly religious fury in many of its citizens. Lastly, and most importantly, flag burning is an act that could possibly cause. On the one hand are those who regard burning the american flag as a form of blasphemy a sin against civil religion in america tantamount a sin against an established church. Burning the flag will be of value to both an academic and a general audience, particularly to civil libertarians, flag buffs, and those interested in popular media, american politics, modern american history, and constitutional law. Court ruling, opponents of flag burning continued to fight to prevent it. The argument that flag burning is outside first amendment protection relies on the same argument that the government made in stevens that the supreme court can, and should, recognize a special new exception to the first amendment because burning the flag is so uniquely awful and represents such lowvalue speech. Apr 18, 2007 gauging from the last presidential election, americans equate a perceived inability to hold a flag with an inability to hold a gun. This soldiersdiesoprotesterscanburnflags slogan has become a mantra repeated everywhere. Lastly, and most importantly, flag burning is an act that could possibly cause a large amount of violence if done in a public arena. Many american believe that flag desecration emerged initially during the vietnam war era, but the history of this caustic form of protest can be traced to the period leading up to the civil war. Republicans are much more likely than democrats to support an amendment banning flag burning. While people have the right to protest and say what they want through words or actions, it is wrong to desecrate ones country by burning the flag because it is disrespectful to the ones who have fought for the country. Moral panic and the criminalization of protest social.
They believed its physical destruction posed a serious threat to the country and demanded a. Jul 02, 2015 a group of flagburning antinypd protesters needed new yorks finest to save their skin from a gang of angry bikers who tried to pummel them in a brooklyn park for setting old glory ablaze. The act of flag burning can be comparable to the burning of the cross by the ku klux klan. Presidentelect donald trump proposed on tuesday a penalty including possible jail time or loss of citizenship for burning the american flag, in spite of two us supreme court rulings that. Lastly, it is an unnecessary practice and can easily be replaced with peaceful negotiation head 4.
Black flags is a chilling, well written examination of the events that led to the formation of isis. The flag desecration amendment often referred to as the flagburning amendment is an american proposed law, in the form of constitutional amendment to the bill of rights, that would allow the u. In 1984, in front of the dallas city hall, gregory lee johnson burned an american flag as a means of protest against reagan administration policies. Two people have been arrested after a violent clash between trump supporters and a group of communists following a flag burning in front of. Man battles to keep protestors from burning an american flag duration. In order to try to get around constitutional challenges, the law prohibited all types of flag desecration, with the exception of burning and burying a wornout flag. Dec 06, 2016 ap photohasan jamaliprotesters are burning and trampling upon the american flag again. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. This amendment states that the united states congress has to allow the expression of political views even if it is through the burning of the united states flag. Flag burning and desecration is offensive precisely because it is political. The second argument against flag burning is that there are many other ways for someone to express their dislike for the american democratic system than to burn one of its most sacred objects. While flag burning is highly offensive, it is none the less a means of expression and is protected by the constitution of. For additional uptotheminute information, you might want to try yahoos coverage of the flag amendment.
A majority of americans support a constitutional amendment that would allow congress and state governments to pass laws to make it illegal to burn the americans flag. Flag burning constitution of united states of america 1789. The denial of the right to burn the flag is the assertion of the government to rule the people. Flag burning a persuasive essay 1044 words bartleby. To some, including president george bush and many members of congress, the flag was a sacred symbol of american freedoms.
In reaction to the johnson decision, which only applied to the texas flagdesecration law, congress passed a national antiflag burning law called the flag protection act of 1989. The great 1989 1990 american flag desecration controversy robert justin goldstein on. Reasons to oppose the flag desecration amendment american. Apr 18, 2016 the truth is why should they respect a flag that symbolizes a country that allows and perpetuates their racial struggle. Public support is lower for a constitutional amendment that would prohibit burning or desecrating the flag outright. Nov 29, 2016 johnson, the case that made burning the flag legal. Congress needs to fight fire with fire by responding to the symbolic act of burning old glory with symbolic action. Creating this shock of the burning of the american flag brought attention to the issues at hand for blacks in america. Flagburner fights back with federal lawsuit new lenox. This is a highly subjective question perhaps quora should create a topic subjective questions phrased in objective terms edit. Flag burning causes intense clash between cops and commies at rnc2016 press for truth. Speaker, this amendment will not even reach the majority of cases of flag burning. Eichman, the court struck down that law as unconstitutional as well, in another 54 decision. Nov 29, 2016 presidentelect donald trump proposed on tuesday a penalty including possible jail time or loss of citizenship for burning the american flag, in spite of two us supreme court rulings that.
As for my viewpoint, i see the amendment as very unnecessary and very dangerous. Americas flag is a symbol of its greatness, democracy and freedom. Some countries have laws forbidding methods of destruction such as burning in public or forbidding. Mar 14, 2007 when i see someone burning a flag i get offended for different reasons. Jul 20, 2016 a flag burning protest turned chaotic outside quicken loans arena on wednesday afternoon as a total of 17 people were arrested and two officers suffered minor injuries. Revolutionary communist party activists initiated a flag burning in front of white house. Donald trump has tweeted that he wants to jail anyone who sets fire to the stars and stripes. Because the first amendment was designed to protect political expression. An american flag was set on fire as a protest against us president donald trumps salute to america military parade.
Five things to know about the case that made burning the flag. Jan 26, 2015 looking through texas vs johnson, we examine the constitutional arguments foragainst flag burning. Flag burning or desecration american civil liberties union. No one gave a damn about moral values when they thought back to those towers burning. Johnson appealed his conviction and his case eventually went to the supreme court.
Police were able to quickly put out the flames using a fire extinguisher. This amendment states that the united states congress has to allow the expression of political views even if. A history of flagburning and flag desecration laws in the u. The flag is a symbol, and burning it doesnt harm the united states any more than it hurts someone when you secretly flip them off over the phone. Freedom cannot survive if exceptions to the first amendment are made when someone in. Cole was one of the attorneys for the defendants in the case argued today. Nov 29, 2016 the flag is a symbol, and burning it doesnt harm the united states any more than it hurts someone when you secretly flip them off over the phone. You strive for world peace yet stand ready to fight oppression. Flag burning causes intense clash between cops and commies. Soldiers dont fight so protesters can burn the flag they. Public support for constitutional amendment on flag burning. Apr 29, 2016 it should be noted that burning an american flag is protected as an expression of freedom of speech. Weenies burn flag to protest cops, get attacked by bikers.
The truth is why should they respect a flag that symbolizes a country that allows and perpetuates their racial struggle. Given the existence of alternative methods of expression that do not harm these ideals of national unity, the balance is in favour of the. Street fight breaks out over flag burning duration. During a political protest during the 1984 republican convention, gregory lee johnson was arrested for burning an american flag. When i see an american burning an american flag i am more offended than when a foreigner burns a flag. The flag is designed to represent america and everything we stand for, fight for and represent. Five things to know about the case that made burning the. A flagburning protest turned chaotic outside quicken loans arena on wednesday afternoon as a total of 17 people were arrested and two officers suffered minor injuries.
Fortyeight states once banned burning the american flag the history of trying to prevent americans from burning their flag is a long one. For older news articles, please see the flag burning news archive. America is ruled by the people, not the government, and it is in fact our patriotic duty, at this juncture to assert that duty. Flag burning and ensuing fight shuts down pennsylvania avenue in. I am not too excited about this process, and certainly i am not very excited about this proposal to amend the constitution. Gauging from the last presidential election, americans equate a perceived inability to hold a flag with an inability to hold a gun. Jan 12, 2017 flag burner fights back with federal lawsuit new lenox, il photos depicting an urbana man burning an american flag stirred the wrath of the internet.
The aclu has led organizing efforts against legislative attempts to ban flag desecration. The expressive act, burning a flag, which this amendment attempts to curtail, is exceedingly rare. Johnsons conviction for flag desecration is inconsistent with the first amendment. Every action deserves a reaction this instance should be prison.
The court first found that johnsons burning of the flag was expressive conduct protected. Jun 29, 2006 a majority of americans support a constitutional amendment that would allow congress and state governments to pass laws to make it illegal to burn the americans flag. Flag desecration is the desecration of a flag, violation of flag protocol, or a various set of acts. Flagburner fights back with federal lawsuit new lenox, il. I have heard many people argue that flag burning is worse than book burning. We can imagine no more appropriate response to burning a flag than waving ones own, no better way to counter a flag burners message than by saluting the flag that burns, no surer means of preserving the dignity even of the flag that burned than by as. It should be noted that burning an american flag is protected as an expression of freedom of speech. Furthermore, even if we assume that flag burning is a valid means of expression, the freedom of expression must be balanced against the important societal interests that are represented by the flag. Flag burning flag burning can be and usually is a very controversial issue.
When we see flag burning on television, it is usually not american citizens, but foreigners who have strong objections to what we do overseas, burning the flag. Experience shows that the way to fight political expression with which one disagrees is not to outlaw it, as congress has repeatedly sought to do, but to express disapproval. Trump protesters burn flag block news coverage youtube. Scuffles erupted at flag burning demo in brooklyn on wednesday between anti flag demonstrators and pro flag supporters. Many people are offended by the thought of destroying this countrys symbol of liberty and freedom. Flag desecration is the desecration of a flag, violation of flag protocol, or a various set of acts that intentionally destroy, damage, or mutilate a flag in public. Which is more offensive, book burning or flag burning. Warrick identifies a number of factors that assisted isis rise, including repressive arab regimes, conflict between sunni and shia muslims, and u. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading black flags. Maybe there you can educate oneself on the representation of our american flag. Johnson, the case that made burning the flag legal. Dec 22, 2019 the flag desecration amendment, also known as the flag burning amendment, is a very controversial amendment allowed under the constitution. Flag burning and desecration is offensive because it is political. In a 5to4 decision, the court held that johnsons burning of a flag was protected expression under the first amendment.
414 341 252 662 322 862 771 1102 418 908 139 559 755 646 1385 441 490 1230 311 1380 1598 629 539 215 691 995 752 623 594 736 51 614 583 722 1004 1023 569